Keepnet Phishing Simulator vs Redcoat AI: Side-by-Side Comparison (2026)

Keepnet Phishing Simulator

Security teams at mid-market and enterprise companies will get the most from Keepnet Phishing Simulator because its 30,000+ templates and multi-channel attack surface (email, SMS, voice, QR code, MFA) let you test user behavior against the actual threats your workforce faces, not sanitized simulations. The platform's false click filtering removes noise from automated security tools, giving you real metrics on human vulnerability, and automated enrollment of clickers into targeted training directly ties simulation results to behavior change. Skip this if your priority is incident response automation or you need deep SOAR integration; Keepnet maps strongly to NIST Awareness and Training but lighter on the Detection and Response functions.

Redcoat AI

Mid-market and enterprise teams struggling to stop mobile phishing will find Redcoat AI's Intent-based detection engine genuinely different; it blocks attacks across semantic and tactic variations that slip past keyword-matching systems, which matters when your workforce lives on Slack and WhatsApp. The Pretender module lets you run on-demand social engineering simulations without waiting for vendor-scheduled campaigns, and continuous monitoring against evolving attack scenarios maps cleanly to NIST ID.RA and DE.CM. Skip this if your biggest phishing problem is email; Redcoat is mobile-first and won't replace your email security gateway.