tcpreplay vs Fortra Cobalt Strike: 2026 Comparison
tcpreplay is a free offensive security tool. Fortra Cobalt Strike is a commercial offensive security tool by Fortra. Compare features, ratings, integrations, and community reviews side by side to find the best offensive security fit for your security stack.
CST VerdictBased on our analysis of NIST CSF 2.0 coverage, core features, company size fit, deployment model, here is our conclusion:
Security engineers validating detection rules or stress-testing incident response workflows should reach for tcpreplay because it replays real network traffic at scale without needing production data or live systems. The tool ships with packet editing capabilities that let you mutate captured traffic on the fly, letting you simulate specific attack patterns or edge cases your monitoring stack might miss. Skip this if your team needs GUI-driven traffic generation or wants pre-built attack scenario libraries; tcpreplay is command-line only and requires you to already have pcap files or the knowledge to craft them from scratch.
Mid-market and enterprise red teams will pick Fortra Cobalt Strike for the Malleable C2 language, which lets you reshape network indicators to match your target environment instead of fighting against detection signatures built for the tool's defaults. The shared team server and asynchronous low-and-slow communication model reflect NIST ID.RA and DE.AE coverage, meaning you can run realistic adversary simulations that actually test how your SOC detects slow exfiltration and lateral movement, not just fast attacks. Skip this if your organization needs purple team automation or wants the tool to generate its own reports without manual TTP documentation; Cobalt Strike is built for operators who know what they're hunting for.
