heylogin vs My1Login Self-Service Password Reset: Side-by-Side Comparison (2026)

heylogin

Teams of 50–500 people who've been burned by phishing-compromised master passwords should consider heylogin for its phone-as-authenticator model, which eliminates the weakest link in traditional password managers. The vendor's admin-initiated device recovery feature,letting IT disconnect a lost phone and restore access without waiting for user action,addresses a real operational gap that password managers typically ignore. Skip this if your organization needs deep integration with existing identity platforms or plans to enforce passwordless across the entire infrastructure; heylogin works best as a standalone manager for teams willing to adopt smartphone-first authentication.

My1Login Self-Service Password Reset

SMB and mid-market IT teams drowning in password reset tickets will see immediate headcount relief from My1Login Self-Service Password Reset's Windows login prompt integration, which eliminates the helpdesk call entirely for the majority of resets. The tool enforces NIST PR.AA identity controls through challenge-response and optional biometric authentication, meaning you're not trading security for convenience. Skip this if you need deep integration beyond Active Directory or run a heterogeneous identity infrastructure; My1Login's strength is doing one thing exceptionally well for pure AD shops.