Compass Security MDR vs Nedscaper Managed XDR: Side-by-Side Comparison (2026)

Compass Security MDR

SMBs and startups that need 24/7 threat hunting without building an internal SOC should pick Compass Security MDR for its direct hotline access to Swiss-based DFIR specialists who can respond on-site, not a call center rotating through scripts. The deployment model keeps your data in your own Microsoft tenant while Compass handles detection and containment, and the annual security benchmark gives you measurable progress on resilience rather than just incident counts. Skip this if you're running heavy non-Microsoft infrastructure; the XDR-native architecture means visibility degrades fast outside that ecosystem.

Nedscaper Managed XDR

SMB and mid-market teams without dedicated security staff should pick Nedscaper Managed XDR for its eyes-on-screen 24/7 SOC paired with a named security consultant who does actual advisory work, not just ticket handoff. The vendor covers the full incident lifecycle from detection through forensic recovery, with explicit NIST RS.MA and RS.AN capabilities built into the service model rather than bolted on as add-ons. Skip this if you're Enterprise with a mature internal SOC looking to outsource only detection, or if your stack is heavily non-Microsoft; Nedscaper's integration depth sits firmly in the Azure and Microsoft Defender ecosystem.