Microsoft Defender for Identity is a commercial identity threat detection and response solution by Microsoft. Zscaler Identity Protection is a commercial identity threat detection and response solution by Zscaler. Features, integrations, deployment and the company behind each one, side by side.
What our shortlists say about each one.
Best for: Microsoft shops with on-premises Active Directory
It leads this list because most companies still run on-premises Active Directory, and this product watches it from the inside while feeding the same Defender incidents your analysts already work. If you are a Microsoft shop, it is often the shortest path to identity detection. If your endpoint and SOC stack is not Microsoft, weigh how much of that value carries over.
From Best ITDR Solutions for Business, Fall 2026
Best for: Zscaler customers wanting identity risk checks
It belongs on this list if you already run Zscaler, because it switches on in the agent your devices already run and can contain an attack through the access rules you already enforce. It also helps you fix Active Directory risks with step-by-step scripts. Outside Zscaler, it has little reason to be your first choice.
From Best ITDR Solutions for Business, Fall 2026
Reviewed by Nika (Nikoloz) Kokhreidze.
Identity threat detection and response solution for Active Directory
ITDR solution for continuous identity monitoring and threat detection
See more solutions in this category, or build a security stack from your picks.
Based on what each listing shows: deployment, company size, price and open source.
Microsoft Defender for Identity fits if you need both cloud and on-premises options.
Zscaler Identity Protection fits if you want a cloud product.
Common questions when comparing Microsoft Defender for Identity vs Zscaler Identity Protection for identity threat detection and response.
Microsoft Defender for Identity: Identity threat detection and response solution for Active Directory. Built by Microsoft.
Zscaler Identity Protection: ITDR solution for continuous identity monitoring and threat detection. Built by Zscaler.
The table above shows where their features, integrations, deployment and company size fit differ.
Microsoft Defender for Identity is made by Microsoft. Zscaler Identity Protection is made by Zscaler. The vendor behind a product decides its roadmap, support, and longevity, so check each company's profile before you commit.
Often, yes. Microsoft Defender for Identity and Zscaler Identity Protection are both Identity Threat Detection and Response products, and both cover Active Directory. Use the table above to see where features, deployment and company size fit differ.
Need the answer fast? Best ITDR Solutions for Business picks Microsoft Defender for Identity, CrowdStrike Falcon Next-Gen Identity Security, SentinelOne Singularity Identity Security and 4 more.See the shortlist