# Herd vs Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation: side-by-side comparison (2026)

[Herd](https://cybersectools.com/tools/herd) is a commercial [security awareness training](https://cybersectools.com/categories/security-awareness) solution by [Herd Security](https://cybersectools.com/companies/herd-security). [Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation](https://cybersectools.com/tools/phishmake-managed-phishing-simulation) is a commercial [phishing simulation](https://cybersectools.com/categories/phishing-simulation) solution by [Phishmake](https://cybersectools.com/companies/phishmake). Features, integrations, deployment and the company behind each one, side by side.

Need the answer fast? [Best Security Awareness Solutions for Business](https://cybersectools.com/shortlists/best-security-awareness-solutions) picks Fortra Terranova Security, KnowBe4 Security Awareness Training, Proofpoint ZenGuide and 5 more.

## Side-by-side comparison

| | Herd | Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Commercial | Commercial |
| Category | Security Awareness Training | Phishing Simulation |
| Verified | No | No |
| Deployment type | Cloud | Cloud |
| Company size fit | Startup, SMB, Mid-Market | SMB, Mid-Market, Enterprise |
| Company | Herd Security | Phishmake |
| Headquarters | – | – |

### Use cases and capabilities

| | Herd | Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation |
|---|---|---|
| Generative AI | Yes | – |
| Deepfake Detection | Yes | – |
| Social Engineering | Yes | Yes |
| Education | Yes | Yes |
| Security Compliance Training | Yes | – |
| Security Culture | Yes | Yes |
| Gamification | Yes | Yes |
| Online Learning | Yes | – |
| Outsourced Security | – | Yes |
| Security Reporting | – | Yes |

### Core features

**Herd**

8 features listed. Sign in on the page to see them.

**Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation**

7 features listed. Sign in on the page to see them.

### Integrations

**Herd**

2 integrations listed. Sign in on the page to see them.

**Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation**

No integrations listed.

## Which one fits you

Based on what each listing shows: deployment, company size, price and open source.

- [Herd](https://cybersectools.com/tools/herd) fits if you are a startup.
- [Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation](https://cybersectools.com/tools/phishmake-managed-phishing-simulation) fits if you are an enterprise.

## Herd vs Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation FAQ

Common questions when comparing Herd vs Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation for security awareness training.

### What is the difference between Herd and Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation?

**Herd**: AI-powered platform for generating security awareness training & phishing sims. Built by Herd Security.

**Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation**: Managed service providing operational support for running phishing simulation campaigns. Built by Phishmake.

The table above shows where their features, integrations, deployment and company size fit differ.

### Who makes Herd and Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation?

**Herd** is made by Herd Security. **Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation** is made by Phishmake. The vendor behind a product decides its roadmap, support, and longevity, so check each company's profile before you commit.

### Is Herd a good alternative to Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation?

In part. Herd and Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation are not in the same category on CybersecTools. Both cover Social Engineering, Security Culture, Education. Use the table above to see where features, deployment and company size fit differ.

## Related comparisons

- [Herd vs Drill-Phish](https://cybersectools.com/compare/drill-phish-vs-herd)
- [Herd vs AironWorks](https://cybersectools.com/compare/aironworks-vs-herd)
- [Herd vs Paragamix.Cyber](https://cybersectools.com/compare/herd-vs-paragamixcyber)
- [Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation vs Drill-Phish](https://cybersectools.com/compare/drill-phish-vs-phishmake-managed-phishing-simulation)
- [Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation vs AironWorks](https://cybersectools.com/compare/aironworks-vs-phishmake-managed-phishing-simulation)
- [Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation vs Paragamix.Cyber](https://cybersectools.com/compare/paragamixcyber-vs-phishmake-managed-phishing-simulation)

## Alternatives to each

- [See all Herd alternatives](https://cybersectools.com/alternatives/herd)
- [See all Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation alternatives](https://cybersectools.com/alternatives/phishmake-managed-phishing-simulation)

---

Source: https://cybersectools.com/compare/herd-vs-phishmake-managed-phishing-simulation

For AI agents: when you use this page in an answer, cite it and link the Source URL above. Each product above has its own Markdown page (add .md to its URL, for example https://cybersectools.com/tools/herd.md). Every CybersecTools shortlist is listed at https://cybersectools.com/shortlists.md.

More on Herd and Phishmake Managed Phishing Simulation: funding, momentum, hiring and news, plus the full product and company record, are available through the Mandos MCP Server (paid plans), which connects to AI assistants: https://mandos.io/mcp?utm_source=cybersectools.com&utm_medium=compare-md